UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
  Brunching UBB
  Wax Intellectual
  Well done, Onion

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Well done, Onion
Roup
Self-Made User
posted September 25, 2001 10:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Roup     Edit/Delete Message
No, this isn't about cooking root vegetables. It's about humor, and dealing with tragedy. And I thought it belonged here, rather than in www.crap, because humor is, ironically, a serious issue.

Anyways, after a week's haitus, The Onion returned with a Special Report: "Holy Fucking Shit - Attack on America"

  • Hugging Up 76,000 Percent
  • Jerry Falwell: Is That Guy A Dick Or What?
  • Rest Of Country Temporarily Feels Deep Affection For New York
  • Massive Attack On Pentagon Page 14 News
  • Arab-American Third-Grader Returns From Recess Crying, Saying He Didn't Kill Anyone
  • President Urges Calm, Restraint Among Nation's Ballad Singers
  • Report: Gen X Irony, Cynicism May Be Permanently Obsolete
  • Dinty Moore Breaks Long Silence On Terrorism With Full-Page Ad
  • Bush Sr. Apologizes To Son For Funding Bin Laden In '80s
  • U.S. Vows To Defeat Whoever It Is We're At War With
  • American Life Turns Into Bad Jerry Bruckheimer Movie
  • Hijackers Surprised To Find Selves In Hell
    'We Expected Eternal Paradise For This,' Say Suicide Bombers
  • Not Knowing What Else To Do, Woman Bakes American-Flag Cake
  • God Angrily Clarifies 'Don't Kill' Rule

Also Point-Counterpoint ("We Must Retaliate With Blind Rage" vs. "We Must Retaliate With Measured, Focused Rage") and a nightly t.v. schedule (Animal Planet: 8:00 - Sharks: Terrorists of the Sea; 9:00 - The Noble American Eagle - Long May She Fly; 10:00 - Fuck Everything, Here's Some Zebra Footage)

quote:
Responding to recent events on Earth, God, the omniscient creator-deity worshipped by billions of followers of various faiths for more than 6,000 years, angrily clarified His longtime stance against humans killing each other Monday.

"Look, I don't know, maybe I haven't made myself completely clear, so for the record, here it is again," said the Lord, His divine face betraying visible emotion during a press conference near the site of the fallen Twin Towers. "Somehow, people keep coming up with the idea that I want them to kill their neighbor. Well, I don't. And to be honest, I'm really getting sick and tired of it. Get it straight. Not only do I not want anybody to kill anyone, but I specifically commanded you not to, in really simple terms that anybody ought to be able to understand."

...

The press conference came as a surprise to humankind, as God rarely intervenes in earthly affairs. As a matter of longstanding policy, He has traditionally left the task of interpreting His message and divine will to clerics, rabbis, priests, imams, and Biblical scholars. Theologians and laymen alike have been given the task of pondering His ineffable mysteries, deciding for themselves what to do as a matter of faith. His decision to manifest on the material plane was motivated by the deep sense of shock, outrage, and sorrow He felt over the Sept. 11 violence carried out in His name, and over its dire potential ramifications around the globe.

"I tried to put it in the simplest possible terms for you people, so you'd get it straight, because I thought it was pretty important," said God, called Yahweh and Allah respectively in the Judaic and Muslim traditions. "I guess I figured I'd left no real room for confusion after putting it in a four-word sentence with one-syllable words, on the tablets I gave to Moses. How much more clear can I get?"

"But somehow, it all gets twisted around and, next thing you know, somebody's spouting off some nonsense about, 'God says I have to kill this guy, God wants me to kill that guy, it's God's will,'" God continued. "It's not God's will, all right? News flash: 'God's will' equals 'Don't murder people.'"

...

Growing increasingly wrathful, God continued: "Can't you people see? What are you, morons? There are a ton of different religious traditions out there, and different cultures worship Me in different ways. But the basic message is always the same: Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Shintoism... every religious belief system under the sun, they all say you're supposed to love your neighbors, folks! It's not that hard a concept to grasp."

"Why would you think I'd want anything else? Humans don't need religion or God as an excuse to kill each other—you've been doing that without any help from Me since you were freaking apes!" God said. "The whole point of believing in God is to have a higher standard of behavior. How obvious can you get?"

"I'm talking to all of you, here!" continued God, His voice rising to a shout. "Do you hear Me? I don't want you to kill anybody. I'm against it, across the board. How many times do I have to say it? Don't kill each other anymore—ever! I'm fucking serious!"

Upon completing His outburst, God fell silent, standing quietly at the podium for several moments. Then, witnesses reported, God's shoulders began to shake, and He wept.




I found this whole issue of the Onion not only extremely funny, but extremely helpful. It's a tough tightrope to walk when writing satire about an event like this, but I think the Onion succeeded in crossing to the other side without falling off.

The best humor is that which not only makes you smile, but makes you think, as well. And here, as well, the Onion succeeds in my opinion. It would have been easy to be flippant, or to ignore the issue entirely. Either would have been a mistake. By taking a humorous look at event of such magnitude, I feel a real service is performed; where we can come together and "deal with it" through the common bond of a chuckle or titter.

And for this, they have my thanks.

IP: Logged

Y2Karen
Cereal Subunit
posted September 26, 2001 12:09 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Y2Karen   Click Here to Email Y2Karen     Edit/Delete Message
God Angrily Clarifies 'Don't Kill' Rule

IP: Logged

ThePet
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 06:50 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for ThePet   Click Here to Email ThePet     Edit/Delete Message
I love their Child Tips...

Sure, it's hilarious to explain to a child those things, but at the same time they're explaining the whole situation to everyone who reads it.

IP: Logged

bellaboops
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 07:08 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bellaboops   Click Here to Email bellaboops     Edit/Delete Message
Thanks for posting that, Roup. I'd forgotten about the Onion lately... great site it is.

This is a successful use of humor in dealing with a sensitive issue. And to me, it's an indication that we are beginning to move on. At the risk of sounding corny, I do sincerely hope that we will always keep the feelings of brotherhood and tolerance and care for our fellow human beings that this tragedy has awakened. I like to think that something good has come out of it all.

IP: Logged

Owlet
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 07:09 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Owlet   Click Here to Email Owlet     Edit/Delete Message
Hysterical *and* touching. Those people are brilliant.

IP: Logged

Jesse Dangerously
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 07:58 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Jesse Dangerously   Click Here to Email Jesse Dangerously     Edit/Delete Message
Oh my God... I cried reading that God article.

That was amazing. I didn't really know they had it in them. I knew that they were secretly compassionate people, even if in the abstract they can often say really terrible things... but this really surpasses my expectations.

I had only read the main page when the site became unavailable this morning. I guess everyone was waiting for the Onion's take.

That one about the kids denying involvement is pretty heavy, too.

IP: Logged

Morat
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 08:21 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Morat   Click Here to Email Morat     Edit/Delete Message
No kidding. I wish I could load the main page. I'll just have to wait.

Thanks Roup...I got to see some of it.

Reminds me of John Stewart's talk on the Daily Show. He said (in a really emotional monologue) that the best way to prove we won is to go on laughing.

The other part that really sticks out is he said: "The view from my apartment used to be the World Trade Center. Now...now it's the Statue of Liberty. You can't beat that".

------------------
Lisa! In this house we obey the Laws of Thermodynamics!

--Homer Simpson

IP: Logged

Paranoid Android
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 09:28 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Paranoid Android   Click Here to Email Paranoid Android     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
I agree that the perpetrators must be punished severely. But, contrary to what so many knee-jerk, blood-lusting Americans would like to believe, merely capturing and punishing them will not prevent this sort of thing from happening again in the future. No, they must be tried and convicted in a U.S. court of law, so that President Bush can, on live TV, pump bullet after bullet into their bodies, starting with their feet and slowly working his way up. Then, after a great deal of soul-searching and consultation with his top advisors, the president must toss their lifeless, bullet-riddled bodies into a shark tank.
--The Onion's Point-Counterpoint

[This message has been edited by Paranoid Android (edited September 26, 2001).]

IP: Logged

Clickie
Cereal Subunit
posted September 26, 2001 09:43 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Clickie   Click Here to Email Clickie     Edit/Delete Message
I love the Onion. I love them even more now.

IP: Logged

Erratic Assassin
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 10:14 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Erratic Assassin   Click Here to Email Erratic Assassin     Edit/Delete Message
I've been a fan of the Onion since I discovered their website, but this... this edition is nothing less than a work of art.

Until I read "Not Knowing What Else To Do, Woman Bakes American-Flag Cake", I would have told you that it was impossible to be simultaneously sardonic and deeply moving in the same article. I know better now.

quote:
"I baked a cake," said Pearson, shrugging her shoulders and forcing a smile as she unveiled the dessert in the Overstreet household later that evening. "I made it into a flag."

Pearson and the Overstreets stared at the cake in silence for nearly a minute, until Cassie hugged Pearson.

"It's beautiful," Cassie said. "The cake is beautiful."


I've long considered subscribing to their paper edition. If I can get through to their subscription page, I'll do so now.

To borrow their phrase: "Holy Fucking Shit."

For posterity, here's a link to this edition of the Onion, that should still work when this edition is supplanted by the next:

http://www.theonion.com/onion3734/index.html

[This message has been edited by Erratic Assassin (edited September 26, 2001).]

IP: Logged

RedTwo
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 11:29 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for RedTwo   Click Here to Email RedTwo     Edit/Delete Message
I'm glad I didn't have to start this thread. I was going to, but now its here.

Nobody else has been able to find humor in this situation yet, not that I've seen anyway. The Onion actually came up with a whole issue that was (believe it or don't) tasteful. Well done, indeed.

------------------
Lore> I want to go to the Jehovah's Witness paradise, 'cause you get to pet baby pandas.

babybabble


IP: Logged

Jesse Dangerously
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 11:32 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Jesse Dangerously   Click Here to Email Jesse Dangerously     Edit/Delete Message
You do get it, don't you, PA?

Both views in the point/counterpoint are intentionally wrong. The former blatantly so, the latter more resembling the people I've been arguing with for all this time. People who are doing their best to be calm and rational, but still can't see their way around the helpless rage at the core of it all, and wind up demanding vengeance in a roundabout way because they can't face it directly but they can't dismiss it either.

That's the most daring article in the whole issue. Hands down.

I can't afford the Canadian subscription prices (or I would have subscribed long ago), but I'm buying this issue without question.

IP: Logged

Maverick
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 11:41 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Maverick   Click Here to Email Maverick     Edit/Delete Message
I'd like to think that PA gave that quote the thumbs up precisely because of that. I might be wrong, though.

IP: Logged

Jesse Dangerously
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 11:44 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Jesse Dangerously   Click Here to Email Jesse Dangerously     Edit/Delete Message
Due to arguments I've had with him recently, I'm inclined to think otherwise.

IP: Logged

Paranoid Android
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 11:52 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Paranoid Android   Click Here to Email Paranoid Android     Edit/Delete Message
I enjoyed it. It made me laugh.

IP: Logged

jarbabyj
Scrappy Doo
posted September 26, 2001 12:26 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for jarbabyj   Click Here to Email jarbabyj     Edit/Delete Message
I particularly enjoyed the headline "Massive Attack on Pentagon Page 14 News"

To quote Homer Simpson, "It's funny because it's true"

The Pentagon attack has been practically swept under the rug in comparison to the enormity of the WTC. It's sad.

jarbaby

------------------
Some lives are filled with pain, some with sorrow...some with a chewy nougat center - Tom Servo

IP: Logged

Cropherb
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 12:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Cropherb   Click Here to Email Cropherb     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
"In the movies, when the president says, 'It's war,' that usually means the good part is just about to begin," said hardware-store owner Thom Garner of Cedar Rapids, IA. "Why doesn't it feel that way now? It doesn't feel like the good part is about to begin at all. It feels there's never going to be another good part again."

Yes, yes, 1000 times YES!! Haunting and lyrical is a tone that is nearly impossible to bring to satire. Bravo, Onion!!

I read an account of some college students who were close enough to the WTC when the planes hit that they had to run for cover. Afterwards, they descibed what they had seen as being "like Die Hard." In real life. Sort of sad, yet unfortunately understandable.

IP: Logged

RedTwo
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 12:57 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for RedTwo   Click Here to Email RedTwo     Edit/Delete Message
I've heard the comparison to action movies out of everyone from kids who witnessed it directly to Edward James Olmos (who took flight 11 to LA on Monday). Everyone says it because that's exactly what it was. That quote, Croph, is one that's likely to be taken as real in future.

------------------
Lore> I want to go to the Jehovah's Witness paradise, 'cause you get to pet baby pandas.

babybabble


IP: Logged

RedTwo
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 01:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for RedTwo   Click Here to Email RedTwo     Edit/Delete Message
Pardon the two-in-a-row, y'all, but I wanted to let you know I've sent a link to this thread to The Onion itself. (Not like a human'll get to respond, but still.) The text of the message:
quote:
I'm sure you'll get a lot of this, but I wanted you to see what a bunch of us had to say.
http://www.brunchma.com/archives/Forum14/HTML/000702.html

This link is to a Brunching Shuttlecocks (www.brunching.com) fan bulletin board. The Onion has many readers there as well, and we'd like those at The Onion to know how impressed we are with this week's edition.

Thank you. Good work.


Short and simple. I figured they deserved a chance to actually receive this praise.

------------------
Lore> I want to go to the Jehovah's Witness paradise, 'cause you get to pet baby pandas.

babybabble


IP: Logged

Y2Karen
Cereal Subunit
posted September 26, 2001 01:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Y2Karen   Click Here to Email Y2Karen     Edit/Delete Message
I'm sure they're getting flooded with accolades. Well-deserved accolades.

Jesse> I cried at the end of the God story, too.

I read the Onion-style headlines (from straightdope) Flax posted in another forum, but a lot of those were too directly related to buildings falling, people jumping, etc. I couldn't take those at all. I think what the Onion mastered was the right amount of distance from the horror of the attacks.

Around Sept. 17, when work calmed down enough for me to goof off again, I had my Our Dumb Century with me and giggled at that a lot between stories (editing them). I think there's a cartoon with Arab terrorists raping Lady Liberty ... but then, there are a dozen such cartoons; just substitute a stereotype for the rapist.

Anyway, now is exactly when we need the Onion. And they did a tremendous job once again.

"Thanks, Taliban: 1,000 years of pan-Islamic cultural progress down the drain." — God

IP: Logged

farwell3d
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 09:15 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for farwell3d   Click Here to Email farwell3d     Edit/Delete Message
I must admit that the project 86 fan forum had a lot of attempts at humor over this, but none we're quite funny, and none we're quite powerful enough. They all came close, and it was an effort, but this is the first GOOD humor I have seen.

I must second what was said about the Pentagon attack on page 14, and compliment the excellent use of a Simpsons quote.

IP: Logged

Miyu
Self-Made User
posted September 26, 2001 10:30 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Miyu   Click Here to Email Miyu     Edit/Delete Message
Wonderful, really.

------------------
BUNNY BUNNY PANCAKE PANCAKE -- megalita

IP: Logged

SergeiRichard
Self-Made User
posted September 27, 2001 06:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for SergeiRichard   Click Here to Email SergeiRichard     Edit/Delete Message
That was magnificently sane. Moving, intelligent, true. And funny as only the truth can be. The world needs people like that.

I wish I was as good a satirist. But at least reading them yesterday gave me back some of the fire that had been burning low for the last couple of weeks. If it isn't impolite to put my own work up here, this is the column I wrote today:


SCENE: A secret top-level meeting of generals in a Holiday Inn near the Pentagon. The general with the most stars on his hat takes the podium.

General 1: Gentlemen, I have called you all here to reveal our plans for Operation Enduring Freedom.

General 2: Sir, ‘Enduring Freedom’? What does that mean, Sir?

Gen 1: Don’t you enjoy you freedom, General?

Gen 2: I do, Sir.

Gen 1: Well other people are enduring it. Here [pulls down map] is Afghanistan, which as you may know is somewhat bigger than France, slightly smaller than Texas. Intelligence indicates that Osama bin Laden is, [waves hand at map] there somewhere.

General 2: Can our intelligence reports not be more… precise, Sir?

Gen 1: The same intelligence that didn’t notice he was organising a plot to hijack four airplanes simultaneously?

Gen 2: Ah.

Gen 1: So our problem, gentlemen, is to find him. And we will find him. We will leave no stone unturned.

Gen 3: How many stones do we have there in Afghanistan, Sir?

Gen 1: At latest estimates, two hundred and thirty-four billion, seven hundred and thirteen million, forty-four thousand nine hundred and eighty-seven stones. [Pause] Not including boulders.

Generals in general: [Blink]

Gen 1: Therefore gentlemen, we have no choice. In order to turn over all those stones, individually, we are going to have to occupy Afghanistan.

Gen 4: But Sir! We don’t have the troops to occupy a territory of that size!

Gen 1: When I say ‘we’, I don’t just mean the army, General.

Gen 4: You mean to send the navy, Sir? But… it has no water. The navy has never successfully operated in an entirely dry environment, Sir.

Gen 1: No Sir, when I say ‘we’, I mean the entire population of the United States. All 278 million of us, making 438 Americans per square kilometre. If we can bring our allies on board here that could up it to more than a thousand of us per square kilometre, virtually standing room only. Then let him try to hide!

Gen 2: Sir, are you proposing to ship the entire population of the western world to the, the drought-ridden, sub-zero, famine-stricken, flood-prone, guerrilla-infested… Sir, adjectives fail me. This is insane.

Gen 1: Are you suggesting that this attack on the United States was the work of a rational mind?

Gen 2: Of course not, Sir. I…

Gen 1: And you are aware of the expression ‘Fight fire with fire’?

Gen 2: Yes, yes, but… What will they eat?

Gen 1: [Indicates map] As you can see, Afghanistan has a strategic border with Pakistan. The solution is obvious.

Gen 2: Sir?

Gen 1: Takeaways, General. We will order out.

Gen 3: Sir, over half a billion westerners, living on takeaway curries and squatting in the mountains. It’ll be… insanitary, Sir.

Gen 1: War is insanitary, soldier.

Gen 4: [Coughs] According to my calculations, Sir, Afghanistan will be a huge mountain of… of excrement in just a matter of weeks.

Gen 1: Precisely, General. We’ve done it to them figuratively, now we’re going to do it to them literally. Any questions?

WILL THE DESPERATE PLAN TO FLUSH OUT BIN LADEN SUCCEED? TUNE IN AGAIN.

IP: Logged

Owlet
Self-Made User
posted September 28, 2001 06:42 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Owlet   Click Here to Email Owlet     Edit/Delete Message
(UNsanitary)

IP: Logged

Toon
Shuttlecock
posted September 28, 2001 12:51 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Toon   Click Here to Email Toon     Edit/Delete Message
I can't seem to actually load the Onion's page itself. Anyone know why?

The stuff I've read quoted here is, as has already been said, splendid. "Magnificently sane," yes.
I really, really want to read the rest of it.


Oh, and...
*chokes*
"...flush out"???
Yer sick, SergeiRichard. I admire that.

IP: Logged

Toon
Shuttlecock
posted September 28, 2001 12:51 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Toon   Click Here to Email Toon     Edit/Delete Message
I can't seem to actually load the Onion's page itself. Anyone know why?

The stuff I've read quoted here is, as has already been said, splendid. "Magnificently sane," yes.
I really, really want to read the rest of it.


Oh, and...
*chokes*
"...flush out"???
Yer sick, SergeiRichard. I admire that.

------------------
-=> Toon

"Toon, it's okay -- just think of the config.sys file as bizarre post-modern poetry."
-Rob Wynne on #filkhaven

IP: Logged

I_like_cheese
Cereal Subunit
posted September 28, 2001 12:54 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for I_like_cheese   Click Here to Email I_like_cheese     Edit/Delete Message
A quote from this week's Newsweek from Onion writer Todd Hanson about their special issue: "It's more like the kind of humor that would make a person cry."

They succeeded wonderfully.

IP: Logged

All times are PT (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | So There

Forum title graphics, where applicable, Copyright 1997-99 The Brunching Shuttlecocks.

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.40
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 1999.

Lotion for Scrappy bottoms. (a.k.a. That's the FAQs, Jack!)
provided courtesy of SpcChick